Should Gifted and Talented Education Be Eliminated?

The elimination of gifted and talented education programs has been proposed as a way to save money in public schools. However, some believe that these programs are essential to providing a well-rounded education. What do you think?

Checkout this video:


Gifted and talented education has been a controversial topic for many years. Some people argue that it should be eliminated because it leads to competition and a sense of elitism among students. Others believe that gifted and talented programs are essential for challenging students and providing them with opportunities to reach their full potential.

What do you think? Should gifted and talented education be eliminated?

The History of Gifted and Talented Education

Gifted and talented education has been part of the public school landscape since the late 19th century. The first gifted and talented programs were established in Boston and New York City in the 1870s. These early programs were created to meet the needs of students who were not well served by the traditional educational system.

Over the next few decades, gifted and talented programs expanded to other cities across the United States. By the mid-20th century, there was a growing recognition of the need for specialized programs to meet the needs of gifted and talented students.

In response to this need, Congress passed the Gifted and Talented Children’s Education Act in 1978. This law provided federal funding for gifted and talented education programs. It also established a definition of “giftedness” and set forth guidelines for identifying and serving gifted and talented students.

Since then, gifted and talented education has become an integral part of public education in the United States. Today, there are more than 3 million students enrolled in gifted and talented programs nationwide.

Despite its long history, gifted and talented education is now facing a new challenge: calls for its elimination.

The Pros of Gifted and Talented Education

There are a number of pros associated with gifted and talented education. These programs can provide students with the opportunity to:
-Work at an accelerated pace in order to challenge themselves

-Receive individualized attention from teachers in order to ensure that they are meeting their full potential

-Work with like-minded peers who can serve as motivation and inspiration

-Develop a love for learning that will stay with them throughout their lives

The Cons of Gifted and Talented Education

There are a few key reasons why some people believe that gifted and talented education should be eliminated. First, they argue that these programs are unjust because they cater to a small percentage of students who are already advantaged. Second, they say that these programs don’t actually benefit the students who participate in them, and may even harm them by putting undue pressure on them to perform. Lastly, some opponents of gifted and talented education argue that these programs siphon resources away from other important educational initiatives.

The Verdict

After careful consideration, we have come to the conclusion that gifted and talented education should not be eliminated. While there are some arguments for doing away with these programs, we believe that the benefits outweigh the drawbacks.

Gifted and talented education provides an important outlet for students who are advanced in their academics. These programs give these students the chance to challenge themselves and to stay engaged in their schooling. Additionally, research has shown that gifted and talented education can improve academic performance for all students, not just those who are enrolled in the programs.

We also believe that gifted and talented education can help to close the achievement gap. Students from disadvantaged backgrounds often benefit the most from these programs, as they provide them with opportunities that they would not otherwise have. Gifted and talented education can level the playing field, giving all students a chance to succeed.

In the end, we believe that gifted and talented education is an important tool for educators and should not be eliminated. These programs provide critical challenges and opportunities for advanced students, and can help all students to achieve success.

Scroll to Top